Sunny — A runaway teenager addicted to drugs, the first female Connor had ever met since being taken to Quor-Toth and with whom he shared his first kiss after protecting her from a drug dealer named Tyke.

Cordelia Chase — Connor developed an affection for Cordelia when they lived together after Cordelia returned from the higher planes with total amnesia. After she regained her memories, a possessed Cordelia seduced Connor, and the pair became the 'parents' of the being known as Jasmine.

Faith Lehane — Connor was instantly attracted by Faith's toughness and fighting skills.

Tracy - During the episode Home, Connor's dad made reference to a woman named Tracy and asked if they were going to the same college, suggesting the two were romantically involved. One of his siblings commented (by way of an insult) that she was a vegan.

Illyria — When the two met, Illyria sensed that Connor was lusting after her, prompting Connor to claim he'd always had a thing for older women.